A small episode in British juvenile courts blooms into national issue that troubles House of Commons
In the small English city of Hereford around last New Year’s Day three small boys, aged 13, 11 and 10, got hold of some keys and stole $200 worth of stuff from a railway-man’s hut, a tool shed, a truck and a furniture store. They also took some pencils from a schoolroom.
Haled before one of England’s excellent juvenile courts, the 10-year-old was dismissed and the other two, after due hearing, were sentenced to the care of the Local Education Authority and “to be privately whipped as soon as possible after the court with four strokes of a birch rod by a constable in the presence of an inspector of police and in the presence of the parents if you desire it.”
By last month this trivial case had blown up into a cause célèbre that crowded the war for England’s attention. The House of Commons had grilled the home secretary about it. Petitions against birching flooded the land. And the learned Lord Justice of Appeal, Sir Rayner Goddard, had conducted an inquiry and issued an 18-page White Paper on it.
The public’s picture was that the boys had stolen only the pencils, had been improperly sentenced for all the crimes by four instead of three magistrates, had been cruelly birched without their parents’ presence before an appeal could be made and had been consigned to a hide-out unknown to their parents.
Lord Justice Goddard found that all this was largely nonsense, based on a highly misleading appeal by a Mr. Craze, the solicitor of one boy’s father, and on incredibly slovenly court reporting by a novice 18-year-old assistant at the original trial. The boys were said to be happily boarded out on nearby farms where their parents were visiting them. But a conference in London last week was considering reforms in the British juvenile courts, while everybody tried to forget about the birched boys of Hereford.
About this website Country files: Judicial CP in Britain
Related Articles
-
A Yank at school gets ‘six of the best’
UNITED KINGDOM School CP – March 1958 Corpun file 24948 at www.corpun.com Daily Mail, London (early editions only), 10 March...
-
Young Men’s Crimes
Record On Robbery With Violence Click to enlarge Sentence of three years’ penal servitude was passed at the Central...
-
Cleared of assault after caning boy
The headmaster of Elmwood Junior School, Croydon, Surrey, who gave a boy pupil, aged eight, two strokes of the...
-
Cane-makers see bottom fall out of their market
By David Harrison IT IS a sadistic headmaster’s dream. Thousands of canes in willow, chestnut, ash and ebony. Some...
-
Give erring Teddy Boys a haircut says Old Etonian
UNITED KINGDOM Judicial CP – May 1958 Corpun file 25199 at www.corpun.com Daily Express, London, 17 May 1958, p.5 Express...
-
New laws to limit parents’ right to smack
By Sarah Hall and Lucy Ward The government will today publish proposals to ban parents from smacking their children...
-
Rod and Gum.
Four out of five lads charged at Aldershot yesterday with breaking into a Canteen Board warehouse and stealing chewing...
-
Smiths Wood query
In the 1970s a story hit the front page of the Sun and the local rags about “Three schoolgirls...
