Women

I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

Another Brian
QuoteLikeSharePin Topic
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Jan 29, 2017#2
<div style=”width:100%;background-image:url(“/realm/A_L_123/A_L_trg.gif”);”>Reluctant as I am to take issue with Another Brian I feel it necessary to make a case for Jenny, Éva, and jd19. If they weren’t female contributors then they sure as heck fooled me!

There have I am sure been other genuine female contributors. I make a case for the above three ladies simply because I had sufficient interaction with them in threads here to form a firm opinion about them. I am fairly sure that the TWP quartet were female, but their culture was sufficiently alien to mine to render a firm conclusion difficult.

Several notable fake females have featured here. The most recent of these on which I have absolutely no doubts was debbie112.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
AlanTuringBletchley
626
73
Jan 29, 2017#3
I wish to confirm Another_Lurker’s observation regarding Éva. She and I had some private email correspondence about a variant of one of my Christmas puzzles a few years ago.
QuoteLikeShare

KeithInUK
218
Jan 30, 2017#4
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Hi Another_Lurker,

You said:

Several notable fake females have featured here. The most recent of these on which I have absolutely no doubts was debbie112.

Yes, I gathered a while ago that “she” was found to be a fake, but how did that eventually become apparent? I must have missed that. As you’ll recall, we both had extensive exchanges with “her” over several weeks, and I for one was certainly fooled!

Keith

QuoteLikeShare
neilmc32
172
25
Jan 30, 2017#5
Yes, but debbie112 was quite good though and had me convinced for a while. I never bought into Dr. Dominum’s alter-ego Mrs Beale-Buss although I have to admit “her” Australian school stories were hilarious.
QuoteLikeShare
AlisonW62
36
4
Jan 30, 2017#6
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
I am real honest !
QuoteLikeShare

Another_Lurker
10K
256
Jan 31, 2017#7
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Jan 31, 2017#8
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
TWP lost its credibility in my USA eyes. He/she (singular or plural) seemed disappointed if a week passed without a paddling. A week without a paddling wouldn’t disappoint me. Are they all that different? After he/she (singular or plural) had a paddle inspection there was a power play. The right paddle was selected and the right technique. Bottoms were but never bruised. The right amount tears elicited according to the severity of the offense. I’m afraid the estimable Forum became a conduit for the poster/s boasting as a model educator and as an expert SCP researcher. Am I certain it’s all a ruse? No, but I’m of the mind he/she (singular or plural) became a lot less authentic with the passing of time.

It wasn’t so much their sudden cessation from posting of Renee, et. al., that led me to post infrequently on the TWP threads but my suspicion, as I often mentioned, the thread was becoming a transatlantic penpal. When interests waned new threads were opened. To have researched so thoroughly corporal punishment and subsequently ask UK posters questions that could be answered by a brief Google research may have been to keep the thread alive.

Who knows for sure? It is a reasonable surmise the last thing he/she (singular or plural) wanted was to be ignored. He/she (singular or plural) benefited from A_L’s humor and milestone postings as we all have. After a while the postings didn’t sustain my interests. I initially wrote I missed them. It didn’t take long for me not to miss them at all.
QuoteLikeShare

IbizanHound
42
Jan 31, 2017#9
Hallo all,

I am positively certain jd 19 is a real women Not sure nominating myself as authentic is going to cut the mustard but Another Lurker has kindly put me forward as the real thing
(thank you A_L) so maybe that will do. Is it like one of those gentleman club places? Women can join but only if recommended by a male

Regarding Debbie, I thought it was fairly obvious all was not as it seems but was unsure if Prof N was behind the keyboard. I have no idea why he took on the Debbie identity but felt saddened that he did so as I found the posts he made under the name Prof N far more interesting and thought provoking. Very sad to read he passed away last year.

Not sure if I can post this I have had trouble accessing this site – perhaps I really do need to be seconded by a male!! I have now got a new log in name but prefer to post using my original name jd 19 if possible.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Jan 31, 2017#10
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
<div style=”width:100%;background-image:url(“/realm/A_L_123/A_L_trg.gif”);”>Hello American Way,

Oh dear, there I was arranging silly posts in another thread in the hope of expediting your return and you were in fact here all the time! Ah well, I’m sure you’ll enjoy it anyway!

I am a little sad about your conclusion on TWP. And to think I went to all that trouble to get myself virtually paddled by blonde Jessica Simpson look alike former University cheerleader Porsche 911 owning Michelle!

Seriously, I think you perhaps have not given sufficient weight to the pressures TWP were under from those seeking to identify and out them for their pro-paddling Blog and the influence that may have had on their decision to stop posting here.

A number of things concerning the identities of TWP went on off-Forum. I recall no suggestion that they were other than female, though as you might expect they probably didn’t match the descriptions they presented in the blog and here

I have to strongly disagree with your statement that:

I would remind you that the actual number of claimed paddlings relative to the period involved represented a pretty low incidence of SCP in the various schools. I can’t recall the exact figures, though I may be able to locate them, but in Renee’s first two years as Middle School Discipline AP it was something like 12 paddlings per year for an 800 pupil school. Further you may recall that Renee’s philosophy was that she didn’t care if ISS was bursting at the seams, the paddle was only going to be used for certain specific offences and no amount of pleading from students or parents was going to get the paddle substituted where the sentence was ISS.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
JulieTX
60
Jan 31, 2017#11
Yes, I am indeed female. And, everything I’ve posted has been truth and not fantasy.

I don’t know enough about this Debbie112 to know about her. She responded to one of my first posts on here, but I don’t remember much about it. Is “she” indeed a “he”?

Regarding the Teachers Who Paddle(TWP), I have read a little bit of their blog. I must say that if they were faking, they certainly did a good job at it. Having gone to a school in Texas myself, they sure sounded like teachers that I remember. Another thing is that the paddlings they described sounded very reasonable, non-abusive, and similar to the paddlings that I remember from elementary school. The paddlings sound only disciplinary and NOT sexual or erotic. They certainly sound like real teachers to me. The only thing that concerns me is why they feel the need to write such a blog. It makes me uncomfortable that teachers would feel the need to discuss the paddlings they have given. Although the paddlings they describe are not abusive or sexual, I still wonder if there is not some sort of pleasure there. Why must they re-live each and every paddling?
QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Jan 31, 2017#12
There always seem to be just enough paddling with fresh cases to keep readers attention. Between the other teachers there weren’t long interstices between accounts in the blog. There was too much interests in corporal punishment and too little interest in professional matters. How did the blog site accomplish the stated purpose? There wasn’t much information shared about the feedback from that blog was there?. The need to talk about corporal punishment served more the poster/posters and that would never be admitted. What other purpose than titillation was served by the bedroom experiment? By now you should be aware of why I almost address Renee, et al. and not just Renee. I saw the hand of more than one writer.
QuoteLikeShare
larry1951
2,292
79
Feb 01, 2017#13
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
My thanks to all those that have suggested other real women.

The mystery surrounding Jenny is interesting. She claimed –

to have been caned several times on the bottom by both male and female teachers at a secondary school, but never gave any indication as to where in the United Kingdom these punishments took place. She wote about being slippered at junior school, but in one account a man did the slippering and in another a woman.

that she and her husband were practising flagellants. More information can be found on the MisterPoll site where she had conversations with a man who wrote under the name of Dorothy and Dot.

She left this site suddenly and joined a private forum run by a mentally disturbed man in Plymouth. A photograph of her, taken years ago, appeared on that site. There is a lookalke in the Gallery of this forum.

Another Brian
QuoteLikeShare
AlanTuringBletchley
626
73
Feb 01, 2017#14
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
I pointed out this discrepancy back in 2012; this thread also contains Jenny’s response.

You will have to draw your own conclusions.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 02, 2017#15
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

It is good to see you contributing again. I trust that you were not offended by my advocacy of your case to Another Brian. In that context you asked above with regard to this Forum:

I don’t believe that is the situation and let us hope that it never will be!

You also wrote:

Along with some other once regular contributors here Prof.n decided to pursue membership of another Forum. In the course of this process attempts were made to publicise the other Forum and poach contributors here for it. This led to what I refer to as ‘The Great Schism’ and thereafter contributions from those who transferred their allegiance were no longer welcome here. Debbie112 was one of the various characters which came into existence as a result. Unlike those which were simply designed to damage this Forum and were quickly suppressed Debbie112 had some entertainment and informative value and persisted until the untimely death of the originator.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
Feb 02, 2017#16
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

It appears to me that you also think that the Teachers Who Paddle contributors to the blog of the same name were indeed genuine teachers. I think they were both genuine teachers and female to boot, so I am glad to have your confirmation at least as regards the first of those propositions. The fairly extensive contributions by Renee of TWP in this Forum and the occasional contributions here by other TWP members give some indications as to why the blog was started. Essentially the group of friends who comprised TWP were all teachers who felt that their own limited use of SCP was fair and fitting for the offences of recipients and was overall of benefit to those recipients in the longer term and in accordance with the wishes of parents and the overall school community.

They felt that the increasingly strident and sometimes inaccurate anti-SCP propaganda from the abolitionists needed to be countered in the interests of a fair and balanced debate on the subject. You comment adversely on some aspects of the detailed descriptions of paddlings in the blog, though you say that they appear very reasonable, non-abusive, and similar to the paddlings that you remember from elementary school. TWP were at pains to stress that these anonymised paddling descriptions were simply efforts to present the punishment as it really was in the majority of schools using SCP.

No 300lb male principals swinging giant two handed paddles full force onto the bottoms of teenage girls bent over in sexualised postures and filmed by hidden cameras as portrayed in anti-SCP propaganda. Just a caring paddler and witness well known to the offender who, after proper investigation and discussion with the offender and of the offence and penalty, often involving parents, delivered a temporarily painful but safe and usually effective punishment following which the slate was wiped clean and the offender was helped back into the class and school communities. Personally I see no indication in the blog, or indeed in their contributions to this Forum, that any of the TWP members enjoyed administering SCP or that, bearing in mind the time period covered and the size of the schools concerned, the number of paddlings was excessive.

If the ladies of TWP had an Achilles heel it was possibly lack of sophistication. But better to be unsophisticated than cynical. Renee should perhaps have given more thought to the likely impact of describing the ‘test paddling’ she underwent to see how much her school paddle hurt, ” pale skin of my bottom” and “rather thin silk pajamas” and all. Before TWP started to contribute here this led me to initially condemn them as fakes and American Way comments adversely on it above.

Also possibly the virtual paddlings dispensed in the TWP ‘classroom’ threads in this Forum were unwise. But in fairness to TWP in those days I was always testing and probing the validity of contributors. However despite my best efforts to subvert the classroom threads and set TWP on a course that might indicate an unfitting and non-scholastic enthusiasm for CP I got nowhere. Perhaps the 4 swat alternating sides paddling by two opposite handed members of TWP had just a teeny frisson of kink but it was still boring old brace position and nary a hint of any disrobing imposed prior to punishment. None of the single layer PE shorts only requirement rapidly elicited from a less genuine paddling teacher! And compared to equivalent output from that same non-genuine source Renee’s description of changes in technique required when paddling a cheerleader in uniform reads like an IBM technical manual. Very boring, but clearly rooted in reality!

American Way says that there wasn’t much information about feedback from the TWP blog. Sorry American Way but I strongly disagree. Substantial chunks of most editions of the blog are devoted to describing, commenting on, and responding to both correspondence directed to the blog and external articles about it. If that isn’t feedback I don’t know what is!</div>
QuoteLikeShare

2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Feb 02, 2017#17
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
A_L Face the facts and not the alternative facts. At times TWP feedback was as inventive as their paddling accounts.

Keep in mind their fantasies are even more outrageous than yours. I played along with TWP ruse. I didn’t want to interrupt your fantasies.

Fantasize to your heart’s content about Jessica Simpson. A_L here she is writing a corporal punishment notice with your name.

CLICK

Some brotherly advice may be in order. Downsize your fantasies.

Who is this A_L that’s disseminated my pictures all over the internet?

CLICK
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 02, 2017#18
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
Feb 02, 2017#19
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
IbizanHound
42
Feb 04, 2017#20
Hallo Another_Lurker

You said:

I trust that you were not offended by my advocacy of your case to Another Brian. In that context you asked above with regard to this Forum:

Is it like one of those gentleman club places? Women can join but only if recommended by a male

I am not in the least offended I was being a little facetious, Another-Brian has identified only three posters that can be considered definitely female but is open to suggestions there may be more if other posters are positive certain.

Well of course I am positive certain but as posters claiming to be female is the issue in doubt here, then it is somewhat doubtful a female posting to confirm she is indeed a real female is going to be necessarily accepted as truth, hence my rather flippant remark implying that maybe only men can be `positive certain` before a female is accepted as real. Goodness me it is a quandary is it not

Another-Brian I don`t think you are correct when you say Jenny never gave any indication as to where in the UK she was schooled. I am fairly confident she identified the region. I believe the reason she gave for not naming her school was because she did not wish people to judge her school and think badly of it using CP on a regular basis.
QuoteLikeShare
larry1951
2,292
79
Feb 04, 2017#21
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Thank you for your observations on Jenny, jd 19.

Quite a few people are interested in this person because of her unusual claims – caned on the bottom several times at school and severely beaten at home by her parents.

The latest thinking appears to be – she is from the London Borough of Barnet, has passed off her husband’s experiences of corporal punishment at school as her own and, having joined an infiltrated private forum dedicated to the destruction of this one, is too embarrassed to post here again.
QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Feb 04, 2017#22
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Their rapid departure IMHO was more due to concerns about being proven to be phony than anything that would bring them more deleterious repercussions. Renee, et. al., perhaps in a kiddingly way noted my familiarity with the school counties OCR records and wrote that I might even be trying to out them. They did try to locate Sharon from Arizona and Sandy P and found their locations were far from where they claimed to be. She wrote how difficult it was to identify her county by county. See link below.

The more provocative the paddlings the less likely they would be ignored. Details about the attractiveness of the teachers or the lesbianism of a pledge were as likely to heighten interests as were bedroom tidbits from the spousal experiment. The Nashia paddling was a case where she called on the readers to respond rather than to see it die on the vine. Elementary school paddlings were beginning to lose our interests so Nashia came on the scene.

I continue to ask myself the question whether the blog served the intention they claimed. That’s what is most troubling to me. When I became more and more convinced this was a classic case of exhibitionism, I became less and less interested in their posts. From the POV of a USA poster I have the same reason for questioned prof n’s Jackie’s bona fides as I do TWP. I won’t have to worry about a lawsuit from Blackpool. Who misses prof n anymore?

ID February 17 2012

CLICK
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 04, 2017#23
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

My alter ego Another_Lurker is a bit of a wimp and is very reluctant to argue with those in positions of authority, so he has asked me to say that personally he’d be very happy to see Jenny back. His understanding is that rather than being too ashamed to post here Jenny reapplied for membership but was refused and didn’t want to stoop to the level of the rest of them and use a new name and an anonymous proxy. He can’t recall where he heard this, but most probably it was from a sometimes unreliable source who did (use a new name and an anonymous proxy that is).

It has to be said that Another_Lurker has an ulterior motive ‘cos Jenny knew all about that Linux thingy and although he’s now a convert he doesn’t really understand all that stuff about sudos and apts and whatnot and in the old days Jenny used to help him out on technical stuff in this Forum without showing him up. And of course he believes that the worst thing Jenny said about him in the infiltrated private forum dedicated to the destruction of this one was when somebody there likened him to some sort of worm found under stones and Jenny said no, ‘cos those worms were useful for something. Which was pretty mild compared to some of the stuff said about him there!

And now for something completely different: I understand that as usual Another_Lurker has created some confusion with his recent fantastical ramblings in this thread. It may be of assistance if I attempt to elucidate the potentially probable punishment preamble postulated by Another_Lurker in his demented wishful thinking speculations about a fantasy judicial process operated by a former contributor here.

For clarification and the avoidance of doubt the the punishment preamble in question may be better known to long-standing readers of this Forum in an entirely different punitive context where it was allegedly known as the ‘Davenport Denudational Deviation’.

To avoid further confusion and hopefully pre-empt additional questions I will say that as far as I am aware a back view of Another_Lurker walking on a beach in a bikini and feeling moody because he was caned at school the week prior has never appeared in a thread here. Further I don’t think Another_Lurker wears tights, so no problem there then. However there is absolutely no way that he’d have been able to comply with the coiffure condition, so if Dot/Dorothy’s court operated the same rules he’d probably have got extra creasers or cross strokes for that as well as for the wrong sort of nether undergarment. And serve him jolly well right!</div>
QuoteLikeShare
Feb 04, 2017#24
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

In your above contribution you question Jackie’s bona fides. The more sceptical, of which I am not one, perish the very thought, might well say that Jackie never made an appearance here as a sock puppet and thus was quite probably real.

And as regards Jackie’s protégé you ask who misses him anymore? Well I do for one. He certainly had his faults and he attempted to do harm to this Forum and people associated with it. I don’t include myself in the latter category. His hacked (allegedly) US email accounts, the hacked (allegedly) US hosted infiltrated private forum dedicated to the destruction of this one, and veiled threats that consequently I might be hauled across the Atlantic to face Federal charges carrying 100 years to life if you got off lightly didn’t actually cause me to lose much sleep.

However our former contributor had at least one attribute I greatly miss. He knew how to conduct a good argument and when you went up against him the exercise was always interesting!

As I said earlier we’ll just have to agree to differ on TWP. If it helps, you are probably of the majority opinion.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
larry1951
2,292
79
Feb 04, 2017#25
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
For clarification and avoidance of doubt, Jenny has not reapplied for membership to this Forum.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 04, 2017#26
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
AlanTuringBletchley
626
73
Feb 06, 2017#27
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Another Brian remarked, regarding former contributor Jenny,
The latest thinking appears to be – she is from the London Borough of Barnet, has passed off her husband’s experiences of corporal punishment at school as her own …
It is not clear, though, how this excerpt from the Sticky thread
About You:
Gender: Female
Approximate age when punished: 9
Approximate year of punishment: 1966
Crime committed or alleged: Persistent misbehaviour in class

About the punishment
Administered by Head, or Staff member: Headmaster
Gender of staff member: Male
Location punished (Classroom, Office, Hallway etc): Headmasters’ Study
Type of punishment (Cane,Slipper,Paddle etc): Slipper
Number of strokes: 4
Applied to (Hand, Bottom, Legs etc): Bottom.
Position adopted (Standing, Bending over Chair, Desk etc): Bending over, hands on a chair seat.
State of dress (Over Trousers/Skirt, panties, bare etc): Skirt lifted.
Privacy (In private, In front of Class, With another teacher etc): With the school secretary as witness.
Click to expand…
should be modified if indeed this punishment was received by Jenny’s husband rather than by Jenny herself.
QuoteLikeShare
stujos
219
20
Feb 06, 2017#28
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Alan, that’s all very well, but it is most unlikely Jenny’s husband would have had his skirt lifted! Unless he was from Scotland, of course!

On a general note, why can’t people be a bit more tolerant? Some contributors may be fakes, but we will never know for sure, so give them the benefit of the doubt, until you have proof. Surely, on sites like these, it doesn’t really matter anyway. It’s true if we want it to be true, and the more lurid the description, the more we enjoy reading them.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 06, 2017#29
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

You said above:

I have probably done as much outing of what I believed to be fakes as any ordinary contributor still posting, though with our much reduced contributor levels I’ve pretty much gone into retirement on that front. I’ve always tried to work on the principle of laissez-faire unless I felt the fake contributor was trying to harm the Forum in some way or was being unfairly used to support someone else’s position in an argument. In such cases if I could accrue evidence that the contributor concerned was fake I’ve publicised it.

You also said:

I think it does matter, at least in the circumstances mentioned. I’d like the Forum to continue, and although they might not have been obvious to everyone there have been some serious efforts to precipitate situations where it might have been closed by Network54. Further I take arguments that I have here on serious topics seriously. I don’t see why I should put up with my opponent’s position being supported or apparently verified by fake characters, and I don’t think that anyone else should have to put up with that either.

And finally you said:

Hmm, would that the first bit was correct! However in the real world it certainly isn’t. That said, personally I’m quite happy to read fiction here provided it doesn’t do any harm and it doesn’t overly decorate itself in the trappings of truth. I’ve written a fair bit of light-hearted fiction here myself , but I’d be absolutely amazed and quite worried if anybody took it as truth.

As regards Jenny, personally I’m very happy to accept that Jenny was exactly what she said she was and I’d be pleased to see her contributing again. I’m also happy to accept that others may consider that they have evidence to the contrary and therefore do not share my opinion.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
Feb 06, 2017#30
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
23C
Feb 07, 2017#31
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
I have corresponded with Jenny personally for a number of years and can confirm that she is a genuine member of the female sex.
QuoteLikeShare
KKxyz
3,590
53
Feb 07, 2017#32
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Very few who contribute to this forum, or who lurk here, want or can afford to have their true identities revealed. Most contributors adopt a disguise, identity or character of greater or lesser sophistication to hide their true identity. Indeed, in real life there is a conscious or unconscious difference between our public and private personas. We show different sides of our personality to family, friends, foes, work mates, etc. Changing one’s declared gender can be a means of disguise although one that is difficult to do plausibly.

Good fiction can be more illuminating of the human condition than bald non-fiction or compilations of facts. Practice is required to write good fiction. A local novelist of note was bemused and delighted when an irate reader accused him of “making it all up”. It seems the reader had become so engrossed in the story that they temporally mistook it for reality.

Some contributors to this forum want to test their fiction writing skills and to see how far they can go before they are challenged. I also enjoy seeing how far they get. When will their blatantly or subtly tall stories be challenged? Can they be lead down the garden path into a trap?

There can be great merit it putting oneself in the position of others. How else can you see the world from their perspective? If you want to understand the world as experienced by a woman try being one for a while.

I see no great harm in men posting here as women – if they do it well and not to cause harm to the forum or its members.
QuoteLikeShare
larry1951
2,292
79
Feb 08, 2017#33
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
As a member of the same private forum to which Jenny belongs, Mike M will know how devious this woman can be.

Read ‘The need to deter bad behaviourˋ from 2013 on this forum and be amazed at Jenny, writing as MM, pretending to be a retired teacher.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 08, 2017#34
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
CM45
4
Feb 08, 2017#35
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Humpty Dumpty sat on the wal

The town where Jenny went to school

she didn’t arrive by horse and carriage

The school attended was ****** ********
QuoteLikeShare
23C
Feb 09, 2017#36
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Let me make it clear that neither am I a member of a private forum nor am I MM who has posted on this forum. At one time I used the nic PC21 – see Unease about Matrices for instance.

QuoteLikeShare
hcsj44
1,211
Feb 09, 2017#37
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Another_Lurker wrote: I thought MM was male and lived not a thousand miles from Lytham St Annes!

Indeed, I would be very surprised if MM was anyone other than the person A_L thought it to be.

QuoteLikeShare
larry1951
2,292
79
Feb 09, 2017#38
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
The word was that Jenny wanted to invite PC21/Mike M to be a member of the private forum but the invitation was never extended for fear that PC21/Mike M would become a mole.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 09, 2017#39
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
Feb 10, 2017#40
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

Fear not, I don’t believe anybody has suggested that you were MM and I am sure others besides me recall you well as PC21 from the happy days of the matrices threads and ‘The Daily Matrix’ (on which I recall you were sometimes quite complimentary). Various people were party to at least some of the goings on in the not so secret Forum. I recall the suggestion that you be considered for membership as mentioned by Another Brian. Clearly Lotta also recalls this, but not the outcome.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 10, 2017#41
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Feb 10, 2017#42
Brian ONC

Posted Feb 10, 2017 11:00 AM

“It is quite wrong of my alter ego Another_Lurker to be so dismissive of former contributor MM. We know that MM was real because HERE is a picture of her.”

CLICK

In reference to the HERE image Cherry Nudes Website access difficulties has nothing to do with its content.

http://www.websitedown.info/cherrynudes.com

An observation is not a censure.

CLICK
QuoteLikeShare
AlanTuringBletchley
626
73
Feb 10, 2017#43
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
If you get a “forbidden” notice, it’s probably because the website detects that you have been redirected from somewhere. So, what do you do?

Simples! You highlight the address from the top of your web browser, and copy it to the clipboard (Ctrl-C). Then you delete the address from the browser (just press the delete key)1. Finally, you paste the copied address back (Ctrl-V) and press Return. Then you’ll have “typed in” the address yourself, and — with luck — you’ll be allowed in.

Happy to help! 2

1. Strictly speaking, this step isn’t necessary; but deleting the address allows you to see that you really have pasted it back.
2. Yes I know that this should really be in Computing Corner.
QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Feb 10, 2017#44
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Alan Turing: Thanks. American Way
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Feb 10, 2017#45
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

Sorry you had problems with the picture.

Hello Alan Turing,

Thanks for sorting out access for American Way. Very well diagnosed!

Very strange. I can’t reproduce the problem in Opera Beta or Chromium, but get it in Firefox. I haven’t tried in Windows yet though. I have Safari on the Windows m/c, which I presume is the browser American Way uses, plus a stack of other browsers, but Windows is just too much hassle and too slow so I’ve more or less given up on it for most things.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Aug 19, 2017#46
<div style=”width:100%;background-image:url(“/realm/A_L_123/A_L_trg.gif”);”>Hello jd 19,

It is good to see you contributing again. I trust that you were not offended by my advocacy of your case to Another Brian. In that context you asked above with regard to this Forum:

I don’t believe that is the situation and let us hope that it never will be!

You also wrote:

Along with some other once regular contributors here Prof.n decided to pursue membership of another Forum. In the course of this process attempts were made to publicise the other Forum and poach contributors here for it. This led to what I refer to as ‘The Great Schism’ and thereafter contributions from those who transferred their allegiance were no longer welcome here. Debbie112 was one of the various characters which came into existence as a result. Unlike those which were simply designed to damage this Forum and were quickly suppressed Debbie112 had some entertainment and informative value and persisted until the untimely death of the originator.</div>
Click to expand…
The true identity of “debbie112” came to me as a surprise. It was at the posting of this May 25, 2016 video when I was virtually certain that the she was a he. My first suspicions were when the narrated paddling always ended in tears. Why would that matter so much?

The severity of that paddling in the video, in spite of the number of swats, would be tolerable by some community standards for 16-year-olds. IMHO in all cases there would be marks and in most cases not enduring ones lasting for any significant number of days.

CLICK

Maybe our prayers were comforting. He had an affinity to the southern woman as in “Jackie” and “TWP” that no one could deny.

January 25, 2016

CLICK

Scroll all the way to the bottom

CLICK

FYI

CLICK
QuoteLikeShare
Aug 19, 2017#47
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Scroll all the way down alphabetically to view information in the boxes and not all the way down to the bottom of the page.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Aug 19, 2017#48
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
dane
405
20
Aug 19, 2017#49
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
twp seems to have had a pretty big online presence, the site may not have been truthful, but it was more than just a sockpuppet persona… or are you saying it was merely their manifestation here that some thought was sockpuppetry?
QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Aug 19, 2017#50
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
A_L I have my reasons to suspect TWP of more than just fogging to protect themselves against the anti-SCP zealot backlash. You’re right about the mileage. I’m closer and in more ways than geographically. Why did TWP receive few paddling teacher testimonials? I would imagine she would have published them rather than expressing disappointment that she had no paddling to report for her readers. Do more schools use less severe paddles or do more school use corporal punishment in a moderate manner because of her blog? Why discontinue her blog to post here if she wanted to outreach to fellow teachers? She was much too informed about corporal punishment for someone that claimed she just discovered Corpun.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Aug 19, 2017#51
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

Hello dane,

Personally I believe that TWP were more or less what they said they were, both in their Weblog and here. While most contributions here were from the TWP member using the name ‘Renee’ I believe that ‘Wendy’, ‘Jenny’ and ‘Michelle’ also contributed here on occasion. I certainly felt that I detected different personalities and, more importantly, different styles.

No names, no pack drill, but I have seen opinions expressed, some on and some off the Forum, suggesting variously that only ‘Renee’ actually contributed here, that TWP was actually only ‘Renee’, that while a teacher ‘Renee’ wasn’t pale skinned, red headed or petite, and indeed that she wasn’t a teacher at all but liked writing about SCP.

As noted I reject these aspersions. I am absolutely certain that if my paddling by Renee had been real rather than virtual I’d have been dealt with by a petite red headed Molly Ringwald lookalike with a strict demeanour, a mean paddle swing and a Tylenol habit. Further that the experience with sweet natured blonde former cheerleader Michelle would have been less intimidating and painful due to her lack of experience. Why, I might even have asked afterwards if I could borrow her Porsche 911 when accepting the proffered tissue to dry my eyes before returning to class! Not so sure though about Sarah Palin look-alike Jenny who was due to be standing to the right of my presented posterior in that summons to the virtual conference room, delivering the left handed half of the swats. Bit of a dark horse, Jenny! I bet she’d have told Michelle not to lend me the car and given me a couple of extra swats for my cheek! As for Wendy, very keen on our Royal Family, and I don’t think I’d want a repeat of my 3 swat virtual conference room appointment with her! That last swat! And I think adding weight to the paddling arm with all those bangles was definitely unfair!

Seriously you’ll have to make up your own mind. But why do you say, presumably of the TWP Weblog, that the site may not have been truthful? Names and identifying details changed to protect paddlers and paddled I’d say, but otherwise as truthful as any blog. Indeed I’ve heard it claimed that one of your lot, oops sorry, a fellow anti-SCP campaigner, got very close as a result of putting two and two together and making five by following the blog and precipitated the cessation of TWP posts here. No idea if that’s correct though.</div>
QuoteLikeShare
dane
405
20
Aug 19, 2017#52
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
i’ve only read relatively small parts of the twp blog, but some of their incidents, especially when dealing with anti scp parents had the whiff a strawmen about them. i don’t believe they were spanking fetishists by any means, their orientation toward relatively moderate cp of grade school children only would speak against that, but it struck me that their stories had more of a feel of pro corporal punishment propaganda than actual experience.
QuoteLikeShare
2015holyfamilypenguin
4,320
69
Aug 20, 2017#53
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Renee dealt with fourteen year olds. For secondary school is through the eight grade. Search for Nashia in our well-indexed estimable Forum.

NASHIA UPDATE

“Just a quick update on Nashia, the very large girl basketball player who I paddled a couple months ago. It turns out that the high school girls basketball coach was the same “paddling teacher” for whom I was the “replacement paddler”. Hey, one look at that coach and you would NOT want to be on the wrong side facing a paddling from her. As to Nashia, the ol’lady coach nearly run our basket brawler into the hardwood floor. Nashia will be definitely toeing the line from here on out. Why? Rumor has it that Nashia is fearful of the coach’s well-known wrath.

If that is what it takes -So be it!

And some people think I’M strict?”
QuoteLikeShare
dane
405
20
Aug 20, 2017#54
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
i thought in the original blog they said they only advocated paddling in grade school where the students only has one teacher… that seems more fishy… like i said i only read a little bit of the blog and very little/almost none of what they posted here
QuoteLikeShare
Aug 20, 2017#55
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
sorry i misread your post… they are supposedly from a district that still puts kindergarten through 8th in one school, i thought that system was long past.
QuoteLikeShare
JulieTX
60
Aug 21, 2017#56
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Hi. I’ve been absent for a while. Just busy, plus I didn’t think that I had anything more to add. Maybe I’ll think of something more sometime. Yes, I am definitely female. Just curious, how were you so certain? Other than my name, what other indications were there?
QuoteLikeShare
larry1951
2,292
79
Aug 21, 2017#57
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Welcome back, Julie! You have been greatly missed. In answer to your question, you made no secret of who you are.

Keep posting!
QuoteLikeShare
Sep 10, 2017#58
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
It is strange that there seems to be nothing on the net written by Jenny after she left/was banned from this board.

She used to be prolific with posts on experienceproject and femalefirst.
QuoteLikeShare
Anoushkabeau
3
Sep 17, 2017#59
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Hi Another Brian
I can assure you that I am 100% female, I posted as a newbie a while back but only received messages from another_lurker and wonchop. I concluded that this forum is extremely male orientated. This is why I have not left any more comments until now as I wanted to proclaim my gender. It would be nice to see some more ladies on here but maybe school punishment is more interesting to men as more boys were caned than girls, although both cane and slipper were very much in use in the schools I attended on both girls and boys?
QuoteLikeShare
bripuk
399
29
Sep 17, 2017#60
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
Hi Anoushka
I for one would very much like to hear your accounts of any corporal punishment you received either at school or home. I attended an all boys grammar school so have little first hand experience of girls having the cane or slipper both of which were used regularly in my school.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
Sep 17, 2017#61
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.

QuoteLikeShare
KKxyz
3,590
53
Sep 18, 2017#62
I have followed this forum since its beginning in 2002 and have seen how it has been, and is still being, plagued with men pretending to be women. I have found only three writers who are without doubt female. They are –

Elaine Sibley, daughter of Brian ‘respected, loved, revered’, Sibley.
Ketta on the Isle of Man, now a member of a not so private Private Forum.
Julie of Texas.

If you are positive certain that there are other real women who have posted, or are currently posting, here please let me know.
I date from the days when there were very different expectations concerning men and women, and their roles in society. I was not responsible for this, but I did not oppose it at the time, knowing no better. I was the victim of “conditioning”, nay, brainwashing. I now know that any and all gender bias and discrimination is WRONG.

Please, is it proper for posters to this forum to disclose their gender or to use gender-specific words?

Is it proper to discriminate between men and women in SCP, the Olympics or elsewhere?
QuoteLikeShare
uninvited.guest
2
May 11, 2018#63
I’m afraid I have been a very infrequent visitor to this site, and have no knowledge of the references that previous contributors have made under this heading. But – I have always found the relative absence of female contributors here very mysterious. Over my last eight-plus decades I can’t remember a single real-life non-cyber bloke ever confessing in my presence to ANY kind of interest in corporal punishment. On the other hand (mild exaggeration alert) almost every female I’ve had significant contact with has been delighted to admit to a certain element of titillation over the subject – and has often been prepared to discuss their personal experiences, whether as agent or patient, with admirably rueful wit. And – thinking back over those eight decades – no boy of my acquaintance would ever in my day have dreamed of initiating a game of schools, or mums and dads, or any of those other games whose main interest according to Havelock Ellis depended on the lowering of underwear and smacking – oh no, the only way in which any male wuld get involved was as the unwilling victim of a beefy big sister and her buddies. And – well, I may likely have been lucky in my school career, but male teachers dealt with chastisement, whether to boys or girls, in an unemotional business-like way – you crossed the line, you knew the consequences, you got walloped not lectured, and that was that (and this being Scotland, except in PE you invariably were hit on your hands). Women teachers, on the other hand – even nice ones – I suppose I should insert another exaggeration alert, but only so to speak barely – were much more likely to hit bottoms, and to do so without making any attempt to disguise a certain ogreish glee.

Well – it may be that my experience has been utterly untypical. I’m sure it can hardly be true that incivility or verbal bullying on a forum such as this would actively DISCOURAGE women or transes from participating. No, no – the inescapable conclusion I am compelled to draw is that the great majority of your contributors, for reasons that remain utterly obscure to me, are WOMEN masquerading as men.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
May 12, 2018#64
Hello uninvited.guest,

Addressing the readers and contributors of this Forum you wrote above:

…………. the inescapable conclusion I am compelled to draw is that the great majority of your contributors, for reasons that remain utterly obscure to me, are WOMEN masquerading as men.

Drat! Rumbled! Yes, I am indeed female. As I was a fairly naughty girl and at school in England in the era when spankings, slipperings and canings were part of everyday classroom experience, when there were always long queues outside the Head’s study awaiting chastisement, and both male and female teachers lifted skirts out of the way with impunity and whacked on knickers, and then eventually I became a whacking headmistress, I could tell a few tales! But I don’t!

Instead I pretend to be that lad I almost caused to be slippered when I got my first really hard slippering age nearly 12 in the last year of Junior School for talking in PT (more sort of drill in those days). Four hard whacks on the seat of my bottle green gym knickers bent over touching my toes in front of the class. If the boy concerned had had an ounce of gumption he’d have intervened by claiming to the teacher that he spoke to me not vice versa, and taken the whacking instead. It would have been quite amusing to see him having to touch his toes and have his PT shorts pulled up really tight over his bottom to be whacked!

It would have done him good too! He was a very nervous boy, terrified of SCP but very obedient and docile. I didn’t know him well then ‘cos he was in a different class, but I remember that he meekly bent over trapped under Miss B’s arm when he got his leg smacked a year or two before. Not even a wriggle in token resistance while she pulled the leg of his shorts up almost enough to bare his bottom, and then he cried as soon as the smacks started! If I’d been one of the girls in the queue Miss B would have had a much harder job keeping me pinned down while she smacked my leg I can tell you! But she certainly put on a good show. Much appreciated if you were sitting smugly in her class watching any of your classmates and the unfortunates from other classes who’d been caught up in one of her playground discipline sweeps fidgeting apprehensively as they queued up to be smacked at the front of the class.

Anyway, he became some sort of computer person. A typically boring outcome I’d have expected for him. So why do I pretend to be him here? Well I lurked here for some time before I first contributed. It was obvious then, and I’ve seen nothing to change my opinion since, that women could post about being slippered on the knickers or caned on the bare, or having been SCP using teachers until they were blue in the face and nobody would take a blind bit of notice. However if a male reported having received some trivial physical correction in his schooldays, especially if it involved some minor clothing adjustment, or using corporal punishment as a teacher, the Forum’s earnest seekers after the truth would be posting in their hundreds quizzing him about it.

The solution was obvious, and look where I am today! A major contributor, at least according to the Tapatalk statistics which I’m not absolutely sure are correct, loved and respected by all. Well almost all! Like you, I am further totally convinced that many of my fellow contributors are also females masquerading as males.

However the deception does mean that the story can never be told of how, when I started as an upper fifth former at a school which was just going coed, I was the first girl to appear before the all male prefects’ court and be sentenced to the cane, specifically to six of the best, which by tradition boys had to take on the bare bent over the prefects’ court table. Well there was some consternation amongst the prefects when they realised the implications, I can tell you! The right of appeal to the headmaster was quickly pointed out! But I didn’t want to let the girls down, tradition was everything in that school, so I insisted we got on with it in the traditional fashion. The head prefect went easy on me, and it was only a junior cane, but it still jolly well stung!

And of course there was that time while I was headmistress of a boys’ school and the 1st XV rugby team behaved so badly on an away fixture that the school’s reputation was in tatters. I decided that nothing but the most severe and exemplary corporal punishment would suffice and had the janitor resurrect the birching table from the basement, where it had been consigned in 1892. The boys involved were somewhat embarrassed to have to strip and be strapped down stretched out on the table for 12 strokes of the birch on their bare bottoms. Very messy, twiggy bits everywhere, and it was fortunate that at the time I was a county class tennis player with a devastating serve, but it got the message home I can tell you! Just as well though that neither off these incidents can be told in the Forum due to my choosing a male identity, because nobody would be interested anyway.
QuoteLikeShare
uninvited.guest
2
May 12, 2018#65
What can I say, Ms. Lurker, except for – WOW! It does seem that life in 1940s schools north of the border was ever so much less exciting than wherever you wis brung up.

And here was me waking up in the middle of last night with the worm of guilt gnawing away at my conscience as I realised that I had unwittingly, through culpable senile forgetfulness, told an untruth on this site. I once DID meet a self-confessed male obsessive in real noncyber life – half a century ago, in one of your venerable English cathedrals. An ageing cleric attached himself as a guide to my family – and having learned that my wife was a schoolteacher, begged her breathlessly for details about her disciplinary techniques, and specifically what they involved in the way of the raising and lowering of clothing; and my wife responded in detail, without the slightest twinkle in her eye. Now it was true enough that my wife’s attitude to classroom management was uncompromisingly uninhibited; but her reputation went before her, and in real life she very very rarely had to proceed to execution – a raised eyebrow was all it took to provoke embarrassing puddles around the toes of potential troublemakers. When our guide had finally headed off for a pre-evensong gargle I asked her why she had thought it necessary to add so much extravagant icing to the cake. “Oh,” says she, “he was such a sweet old man – it would have been a shame to disappoint him”. Sweet old man, indeed – I’d been restraining myself with massive difficulty over the last forty minutes from planting a vigorous toe or two to the seat of his soutane.
QuoteLikeShare
Another_Lurker
10K
256
May 13, 2018#66
Hello again uninvited.guest,

And this time more seriously:

Do I detect a writing style from the past in your above 11 May 2018 contribution? I think I do, but I am very out of practice in that area so time will tell.

Your final conclusion regarding the gender of contributors here was I trust jocular, as was my reply thereto. However along the way you made some interesting observations, though I don’t agree with all of them. Perhaps we can initiate some discussion and argument about them. How I miss those happy, happy days before the Great Schism, when the Happy Circle was still unbroken and anything up to four or so lively discussions might be ongoing in this estimable Forum at any given time, each involving several people!

First then, are women more interested in corporal punishment, and more ready to discuss their experiences therewith than men, as you claim? Certainly not in my experience. Agreed I haven’t encountered many men in RL who openly evinced a serious interest in the subject, but they certainly exceeded women doing the same thing. And I’ve heard a lot more men than women casually comment, usually with regard to the behaviour of modern youth, that they got corporal punishment for whatever might be at issue when they were at school.

Who forms the customer base necessary to keep the many producers of ‘adult’ CP material in business? Whether it’s women or men being whacked I doubt if there are many women on the subscription lists. I believe that ‘adult’ schools, so called, have little difficulty in recruiting adult male attendees in blazers, short trousers and knee socks eager to have their bottoms bared and bend over for cane, slipper or whatever. However genuine adult females in gymslips craving the same experience are I understand much rarer. I certainly don’t claim that they don’t exist, just that there are rather fewer of them.

As regards feminine reticence in discussing CP I have though noted one exception, and indeed commented on it here in the past, though I can’t find the post at the moment. It may have significance as you say you were educated in Scotland, and for aught I know may still reside there. I have found that women in Scotland do not seem to be averse to admitting that they were belted at school, an admission they make far more readily than their English sisters would admit to having been caned or slippered.

I first noted this as a rather impressionable young man when in the 1960s, at the request of her mother, at whose house on Lomondside I had stayed the night B & B, I gave a young teenager who had missed the school bus a lift to school in Helensburgh. The young lady had no hesitation in urging me to drive faster because she’d be belted if she was late. While I guessed it was SCP, I hadn’t a clue then what being belted involved and I was too shy to ask.

However I pushed the Ford Anglia to it’s admittedly rather low limits and we arrived in time. I recall thinking that an English girl would not only have been unlikely to be caned or slippered for lateness, but also that, had such a prospect loomed, she’d have been far less likely to raise the subject with a young man she’d only met for the first time a few minutes ago!

Since then I’ve met several other Scottish ladies who were quite uninhibited in admitting to having been belted, sometimes even raising the subject without prompting. I recall in Lochaber mentioning to a waitress that I was staying at a particular property. She had no hesitation in informing me that it used to be a girls’ boarding house for the region’s high school and that she’d been belted in there lots of times because the regime was very strict.

I have always put the relative north and south of the border levels of feminine reticence in discussing SCP down to differences in the administration thereof, both with regard to frequency and method. Belting in class by teachers of both sexes, and by Heads, Deputy Heads etc. in more serious cases, seems to have been very widespread in Scotland, and relatively far more girls were so punished for minor (and thus fairly guilt free) offences than was the case with SCP of girls in England. Also belting in Scotland was almost invariably on the hand whereas in England girls were not infrequently whacked on the bottom. Thus a woman in Scotland is both more likely to have experienced SCP with minimal guilt and does not have to worry about questions or speculations as to whether she got it on her bottom, both factors likely to inhibit her English sisters in discussion.

You say that female teachers you encountered were often overly keen to use SCP and apparently sometimes quite enjoyed it. I only had female teachers at primary school, but I don’t recall significant differences in professional detachment and attitude to administrating SCP between males and females. Lady teachers did, I concede, have a tendency to smack legs, specifically upper thighs, which involved clothing adjustment for both boys and girls. Male teachers never used this method, but they did slipper boys, and sometimes girls, bent over and on the bottom, a technique eschewed by female teachers at that school.

I am interested to note that you claim women teachers were more likely to hit the bottom (by implication rather than the hand) and sometimes to enjoy doing so. However you admit to a degree of exaggeration in this. Interesting! Are we talking punishment with a tawse here, and just how much are you exaggerating please? I recall very few recorded cases of the scholastic tawse in Scotland being used other than on the hand in the period we are likely to be considering, and those I do recall involved male teachers. The tawse on the bare bottom was apparently a Sheriff and Magisterial option alongside the birch in certain areas of Scotland when JCP of boys was still current but I doubt any lady teachers were involved in that! Clarification of your claim would be appreciated.
QuoteLikeShare

Notes on Corporal Punishment & Curious Punishments of Bygone Days

Tuckshop tawsing

knee socks

Salvation Army Spanker Martin Howe

Uniforms as part of Discipline

Historical recollections

Ruler on the hand

Schools, Black Children, And Corporal Punishment

Affiliate disclaimer

We would like to disclose that this website may contain affiliate links,

Affiliate disclaimer

This means that if you click on a product link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission.

Affiliate disclaimer

This commission comes at no additional cost to you.

Affiliate disclaimer

As an ebay Partner Network Associate, We earn from qualifying purchases.

Affiliate disclaimer

We would like to disclose that this website may contain affiliate links,

Affiliate disclaimer

This means that if you click on a product link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission.

Affiliate disclaimer

This commission comes at no additional cost to you.

Affiliate disclaimer

As an ebay Partner Network Associate, We earn from qualifying purchases.

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?