Why? What did it achieve apart from enhancing Miss F’s ‘hard’ reputation? Well according to her this later to be Head Girl a lot. Miss F argued that she was a potential head girl. Someday she herself might have to refer girls, probably of a very different nature and background from herself, to the Deputy head, and they may well, in extremis, get caned. What did that look like, and more importantly, how could she do it, if she herself was not prepared to accept this discipline when it was earned? She would be completely morally compromised. ….Miss F ‘won’ giving her some leeway on the ‘normal’ tariff in recognition of her record and contrite apology ( highly unusual)…Years later when I discussed with the now young lady concerned she agreed that the Deputy head, whilst understanding and sympathetic to her plight, was right to insist…for …..The high office carries high responsibility; and as Zeno reminds us all actions carry consequences that you shouldn’t be able to avoid, no matter who you are… ( Alamo values!). …….
The Cane and the Double Standard25
-
Pupils in a Class of their Own for Bad Behaviour13
The real problem, I think, is when fairness conflicts with effectiveness. If the idea is to do the best...
-
Caning from of the Times17
Wednesday, May 20th, 1981 Caning of girls ‘worse than in last century’ By Pat Healy, Social Services Correspondent...
-
Corporal Punishment and The Caning Experience30
Well Mr Farrell I cannot read your mind but it should be clear to anyone who sees it that...
-
The Problem with Over the Knee Discipline6
No attempt should be made to forcibly pull the trousers down or lift a skirt. Still less no attempt...
-
The High Price of Stealing32
Josh recognized this question as this was the same question that mom always posed before giving her children a...
-
Caning on the Hands1
I was never caned on the hand but always dreaded it as it seems especially cruel and must be...
-
Corporal Punishment & The Gender Disadvantage17
When boys behaviour is overall improved by the existence of corporal punishment and there’s a very low chance of...
-
Slipper Replaces Detention1
I wonder if any had the system in their school which was fairly common.That being detention could be replaced...