The birch may not be as bad as all that. Yes, we’ve all read far-fetched stories about romantic poets being given 10,000 strokes; but there are a couple of quotes on the Corpun site by people who were birched on the Isle of Man who said that it wasn’t much worse than getting the cane at school. I read in one of those books about Eton where someone who got the birch not long before they gave up using it (as late as the 70s, I think) saying that he resented the ritual and being made to strip off, but that it actually hurt less than the cane did. Of course, it’s outrageous that young people were ever hit at all; but when he read about a birching it may only mean what the Americans would call “a severe switching.”
Scottish Approved School Punishment17
Related Articles
-
Reactions to the Slipper27
Looking at a few Friends Reuinited references to these semi-private punishments. This first one was from a girl who...
-
Sent for the Cane19
This happened when I was in primary school aged about 10, long ago. The headmaster occasionally visited classes and...
-
Supermarket Weep7
I remember I-Spy books & the fact that in 1959, you got TWENTY points for a man with a...
-
Delay before punishment6
More preparatory noises then perhaps the muffled sound of a harsh feminine voice delivering a lecture in a high...
-
Corporal Punishment References from Buy Gone Days33
The balloon went up in November 1980 when a girl of 15 was caned for absconding, the first girl...
-
And when we got there the Cupboard was Bare7
Most of these types of punishment are characterized by the imposition and negative reinforcement of the power relation between...
-
A Trip to the Head14
Was I excited? Was I afraid? Was I curious? Was I about to laugh or about to cry? I...
-
Plimsols Pumps Slippers & Slippering 5
I also went to school in Birmingham at around the same as her and can confirm that corporal punishment...