Evidence from Royal Commissions (1857-58, 1870, and 1881) suggests that discipline practices did not change much overall in that time. HOWEVER
In Manchester, Br. D. Phelan occasionally flogged boys in the accepted British tradition.
In Sunderland, a mother made complaints about the punishment of her son.
Visitation Report, Leeds 1849: ‘Slapping is used freely’.
Memoirs of Edward O’Flynn who attended North Monastery School late 1840s/early 1850s gives a sympathetic portrait of his teachers – however, he makes it clear that Br. J. Wiseman (author of many of the Order’s first textbooks) used disciplinary practices similar to those used in most British schools – Wiseman ‘made great use of the cane’ flogging boys especially for lying or smoking.
We are still a long way from the extraordinary notoriety of the Christian Brothers.
School Belt47
Related Articles
-
Picking Flowers3
Little as I was, she didn’t spare me, and by the time my smacking was done, I had a...
-
CP behind the Iron Curtain1
As someone who spent a fair amount of time behind the Iron Curtain (when there was one), and since,...
-
School Discipline References32
I have another book somewhere called Life in a Secondary Modern which describes a British secondary modern school of the same...
-
Corporal Punishment in Mixed Secondary Modern23
Teachers could do what they liked within reason and got parental backing in 99% of cases. ( My mum...
-
The Cane in UK Schools39
As headmaster, Mr Ing would have been well aware there was an enquiry afoot before anyone else. Going on...
-
Caned by the Prefect5
Prefects were almost invariably prominent school sportsmen. Academic achievement might get you priv, but seldom prefect. Thus they tended...
-
Caning from of the Times13
Mr. Evans, in his defence, denied liability, and said that it was a term of the contract between himself...
-
School and Home8
Well, off went my clothes, and I cried some more. My mom told me to get my little ass...