The birch may not be as bad as all that. Yes, we’ve all read far-fetched stories about romantic poets being given 10,000 strokes; but there are a couple of quotes on the Corpun site by people who were birched on the Isle of Man who said that it wasn’t much worse than getting the cane at school. I read in one of those books about Eton where someone who got the birch not long before they gave up using it (as late as the 70s, I think) saying that he resented the ritual and being made to strip off, but that it actually hurt less than the cane did. Of course, it’s outrageous that young people were ever hit at all; but when he read about a birching it may only mean what the Americans would call “a severe switching.”
Scottish Approved School Punishment17
Related Articles
-
Primary School Corporal Punishments23
Asked why it hadn’t been mentioned previously, my unintentional flippant rely on “you didn’t ask” hardly allowed the words...
-
This going to hurt you six times more 4
It’s something that is probably impossible to quantify – but even if each stroke of the cane was only...
-
Outside the Heads Office32
Depending on the situation, the number of us present, whether it was the headmaster or one of the senior...
-
A Breath of Fresh Air1
Although I am almost 60 now, I can still clearly remember an evening in the Iowa wintertime when I...
-
A Run Up to Corporal Punishment6
I suspect very rarely, for the good reasons you have stated. If it did happen, it was just a...
-
No Nonsense from Grandma 2
The one thing which was forbidden was to go into the woods. Grandpa said there were wild animals in...
-
Mrs Vickers3
“Good afternoon Mrs McCallum, the waiting is sometimes hard, especially with three children to rear.” “Quite, well let us...
-
Corporal Punishment and The Slipper4
A friend of mine was slippered at home, but her mother was a schoolteacher – so that probably explained...